Wow, what a great locally owned restaurant! My husband and I live not too far away and just tried this place and I feel like we've been missing out! The service was great with a cozy atmosphere, but the food was of course the main event. Not many places start you with homemade bread and a salad anymore, and the starter salad was unique too- topped with feta and a zesty house lime vinaigrette. For our entrees we ordered a steak and the fried chicken sandwich, both did not disappoint. The steak was cooked perfectly and the chicken sandwich's homemade habanero aoili was *chefs kiss*. The fries that came with the chicken sandwich were also very good- hand cut thick and crispy.

Best wings I've ever had. Best ribs I've ever had, so tender you can slide the bones out and eat them with a fork. Amazing French onion soup. Had the calamari before and it was perfect. Also have had the roasted chicken and it was so tender and flavorful. Some of the best service I've ever had. Fantastic atmosphere for a date night. Great drinks too.

We live across the street from Matt and Tony's & order take out frequently. Friendly service & delicious food! IMO, the best cheeseburger in Columbus!
My wife feels the same about their gigantic piece of chocolate cake!
This review is making me hungry, & am thinking this is a good choice for dinner tonight!

My family and I came across this restaurant through Yelp. Our waitress was very attentive and our food and drinks were delicious. We will definitely come back for another meal.

We often order Matt and Tony's delivery to our nightshift job! Our favorite is the Roasted Beet & Pecan salad with the blackened salmon (getting extra of the sherry vinaigrette is a must)! Another fan favorite is the French dip sandwich!